KEGG: bad:BAD_1430
STRING: 367928.BAD_1430
The ATP synthase delta subunit in Bifidobacterium adolescentis is part of the F1F0-ATPase complex, which is responsible for ATP production through oxidative phosphorylation. Similar to other bacterial species, the ATP synthase in B. adolescentis consists of two main structural domains: F1 (containing the catalytic core) and F0 (containing the membrane proton channel) . The delta subunit forms part of the central stalk that connects these domains and plays a crucial role in the rotary mechanism coupling proton translocation to ATP synthesis . During catalysis, the rotation of the central stalk against the surrounding alpha and beta subunits leads to ATP synthesis or hydrolysis in separate catalytic sites .
In Bifidobacterium species, the ATP synthase genes are organized in the atp operon, which is highly conserved among eubacteria . Based on studies of the closely related Bifidobacterium lactis, the atp operon typically includes the genes atpBEFHAGDC, which encode the various subunits of the F1F0-ATPase complex . The atpH gene encodes the delta subunit, while other genes encode additional components such as the alpha (atpA), beta (atpD), gamma (atpG), epsilon (atpE), a (atpB), b (atpF), and c (atpC) subunits. Northern blot analysis has shown that the complete atp operon transcript is approximately 7.3 kb in size, with an additional smaller transcript of about 4.5 kb corresponding to the atpC, atpD, atpG, and atpA genes .
Bifidobacterium adolescentis ATP synthase is of particular research interest because this organism demonstrates unique metabolic adaptations to the gut environment. B. adolescentis produces acetate during fermentation and has predicted genes for biosynthesis of all 20 amino acids, purines, and pyrimidines . The ATP synthase complex plays a critical role in energy metabolism, and studying recombinant expression of its components can provide insights into:
Bacterial adaptation to different environmental conditions
Energy metabolism in probiotic bacteria
Potential biotechnological applications
Structure-function relationships in bacterial ATP synthases
Additionally, B. adolescentis shows significant changes in membrane potential under various environmental conditions, which may be related to ATP synthase function .
Codon optimization: B. adolescentis has a high G+C content and biased codon usage compared to E. coli . Codon optimization is often necessary to improve expression yields.
Protein solubility: The delta subunit is part of a multiprotein complex, and when expressed alone, it may demonstrate solubility issues. Consider fusion tags such as MBP (maltose-binding protein) or SUMO to enhance solubility.
Expression conditions: Parameters like temperature (16-30°C), inducer concentration, and expression duration significantly impact protein yield and solubility.
Alternative hosts: For functional studies, expression in Lactococcus lactis or other Gram-positive bacteria may provide a more suitable cellular environment.
Based on studies with related Bifidobacterium species, the pH of the medium also affects atp operon expression, with increased transcription observed under acidic conditions .
Distinguishing between native and recombinant B. adolescentis atpH can be accomplished through several complementary approaches:
Epitope tagging: Incorporate affinity tags (His6, FLAG, etc.) at either the N- or C-terminus of the recombinant protein. Western blotting with tag-specific antibodies can then distinguish recombinant from native protein.
Mass spectrometry: Recombinant protein can be designed to have a slightly altered molecular weight through tag addition or amino acid substitutions that don't affect function but are detectable by mass spectrometry.
Immunological detection: Generate antibodies against unique epitopes present only in the recombinant protein.
Expression level analysis: Use quantitative PCR to measure transcript levels from native versus recombinant genes, which typically show different expression patterns.
Reporter gene fusion: For in vivo studies, fuse a fluorescent protein (e.g., GFP) to monitor recombinant protein expression.
When designing these experiments, researchers should consider that the ATP synthase complex is regulated at the transcriptional level in response to environmental factors such as pH , which may affect both native and recombinant protein expression.
Structural studies of recombinant B. adolescentis ATP synthase subunit delta face several methodological challenges:
Protein stability: The delta subunit normally functions as part of a multiprotein complex. In isolation, it may exhibit conformational instability, complicating structural analysis.
Crystallization difficulties: Membrane-associated proteins or their subunits often resist crystallization due to hydrophobic surfaces and conformational flexibility.
Functional state capture: The delta subunit undergoes conformational changes during ATP synthesis. Capturing specific functional states for structural analysis is technically challenging.
Complex reconstitution: For functional studies, reconstituting the delta subunit with other ATP synthase components may be necessary, requiring optimization of subunit stoichiometry and assembly conditions.
Post-translational modifications: If B. adolescentis modifies the delta subunit post-translationally, recombinant expression systems may not reproduce these modifications accurately.
To address these challenges, researchers often employ a combination of techniques including X-ray crystallography, cryo-electron microscopy, nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectroscopy, and computational modeling. Cross-linking studies combined with mass spectrometry can also provide valuable structural information about subunit interactions within the ATP synthase complex.
Optimizing PCR amplification of the atpH gene from B. adolescentis genomic DNA requires attention to several factors:
Primer design considerations:
DNA template preparation:
Ensure high-quality genomic DNA extraction from B. adolescentis
Use specialized extraction protocols for Gram-positive bacteria
Consider phenol-chloroform extraction followed by ethanol precipitation
PCR optimization parameters:
Use high-fidelity polymerases with proofreading activity
Include additives such as DMSO (5-10%) or betaine to manage GC-rich regions
Implement touchdown PCR protocols starting 5-8°C above the calculated Tm
Optimize annealing temperature through gradient PCR
Consider longer extension times (30-60s/kb) due to GC content
Validation approaches:
Based on previous studies, researchers have successfully used consensus sequences from the atpD gene to design primers that amplify partial sequences from multiple Bifidobacterium species , which could serve as a starting point for atpH amplification.
Critical expression vector features for successful recombinant production of B. adolescentis atpH include:
Promoter selection:
Strong inducible promoters (T7, tac, araBAD) for high-level expression
Constitutive promoters for lower, continuous expression if protein toxicity is an issue
Temperature-sensitive promoters for expression at lower temperatures to enhance solubility
Fusion tags and purification elements:
N- or C-terminal His6 tag for IMAC purification
Solubility-enhancing tags (MBP, SUMO, TrxA) if solubility is problematic
Protease cleavage sites (TEV, PreScission) for tag removal
Signal peptides for periplasmic or secreted expression if necessary
Codon optimization:
Adaptation to expression host codon usage
Removal of rare codons, particularly for highly expressed genes
Balancing GC content, especially in regions of secondary structure
Regulatory elements:
Strong ribosome binding site (RBS) appropriately spaced from start codon
Transcription terminators to prevent read-through
Origin of replication compatible with desired copy number
Selection markers:
Antibiotic resistance appropriate for the host strain
Dual selection systems for large or potentially toxic constructs
Based on studies of the atp operon in Bifidobacterium, researchers should consider that acid-inducible expression has been observed , which might inform vector design for functional studies of the recombinant protein.
The optimal growth conditions for maximizing recombinant B. adolescentis atpH expression depend on the expression system used, but several key parameters should be considered:
For expression in Bifidobacterium or related species, anaerobic or microaerophilic conditions would be necessary, as these organisms are sensitive to oxygen exposure. Studies have shown that B. adolescentis experiences significant changes in membrane potential and redox activity under various environmental conditions , which may affect ATP synthase expression and function.
Additionally, research has demonstrated that the atp operon transcription increases rapidly upon exposure to low pH , suggesting that introducing a controlled acid stress during cultivation might enhance expression of the recombinant atpH gene.
Assessing the functionality of recombinantly expressed B. adolescentis atpH requires multiple approaches since the delta subunit functions as part of the larger ATP synthase complex:
Binding assays:
Co-immunoprecipitation with other ATP synthase subunits
Surface plasmon resonance (SPR) or microscale thermophoresis (MST) to measure binding affinities
Yeast two-hybrid or bacterial two-hybrid systems to identify protein-protein interactions
Structural integrity assessment:
Circular dichroism (CD) spectroscopy to confirm secondary structure
Thermal shift assays to evaluate protein stability
Limited proteolysis to assess folding quality
Functional complementation:
Express recombinant atpH in delta subunit-deficient bacterial strains
Measure restoration of ATP synthesis activity
Assess growth under conditions requiring ATP synthase function
Reconstitution experiments:
In vitro reconstitution of the ATP synthase complex with purified subunits
Measurement of ATP synthesis or hydrolysis activity
Proton pumping assays using pH-sensitive fluorescent dyes
Membrane potential analysis:
When designing these experiments, researchers should consider that B. adolescentis shows specific changes in membrane potential in response to environmental conditions , which may influence ATP synthase function.
Effective methods for studying interactions between recombinant atpH and other ATP synthase subunits include:
Co-expression and co-purification:
Design multi-cistronic expression systems for simultaneous production of interacting subunits
Implement tandem affinity purification (TAP) to isolate intact complexes
Use size exclusion chromatography to analyze complex formation
Advanced biophysical techniques:
Isothermal titration calorimetry (ITC) for quantitative binding parameters
Förster resonance energy transfer (FRET) for monitoring real-time interactions
Hydrogen-deuterium exchange mass spectrometry (HDX-MS) to map interaction interfaces
Cross-linking coupled with mass spectrometry (XL-MS) to identify proximity between subunits
Structural biology approaches:
Cryo-electron microscopy of reconstituted subcomplexes
X-ray crystallography of co-crystallized components
Nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) for studying dynamics of interactions
Computational methods:
Molecular docking to predict interaction interfaces
Molecular dynamics simulations to study complex stability
Coevolution analysis to identify potentially interacting residues
Functional assays:
ATPase activity measurements of reconstituted complexes
Proton pumping assays in proteoliposomes
Rotational assays using single-molecule techniques
These methods can be particularly valuable given that ATP synthase functions through a rotary mechanism where the delta subunit is part of the central stalk that rotates against the surrounding alpha and beta subunits during catalysis .
Environmental factors significantly impact the function of recombinant B. adolescentis ATP synthase delta subunit, reflecting the organism's adaptation to its natural habitat:
pH effects:
Studies on Bifidobacterium lactis have shown that atp operon transcription increases rapidly upon exposure to low pH
Acidic conditions (pH 5.0-6.0) likely enhance protein expression and potentially alter functional properties
Functional assays should include pH as a variable to determine optimal activity range
Oxygen sensitivity:
Temperature dependence:
Optimal temperature for B. adolescentis growth is 37-38°C
Temperature affects membrane fluidity and protein dynamics
Activity assays should examine a range of temperatures (25-42°C) to determine optimal conditions
Ionic conditions:
Magnesium concentration critically affects ATP binding and hydrolysis
Optimal Mg²⁺:ATP ratio should be determined (typically 1:1 to 2:1)
Other ions (Na⁺, K⁺, Ca²⁺) may modulate activity
Metabolic state:
Research on B. adolescentis has shown that the organism exhibits significant changes in membrane potential when exposed to different environments, including eukaryotic cells, inflammatory conditions, and culture media . These changes may directly impact ATP synthase function, as the enzyme relies on the proton gradient across the membrane.
When interpreting discrepancies between in vitro and in vivo function of recombinant B. adolescentis atpH, researchers should consider several factors:
Protein context differences:
In vivo, the delta subunit functions within the complete ATP synthase complex
In vitro studies may use isolated protein or partial subcomplexes
Complex assembly may be incomplete or incorrect in heterologous expression systems
Membrane environment effects:
Native lipid composition of B. adolescentis differs from expression hosts
Membrane properties affect proton gradient formation and stability
Reconstitution in proteoliposomes may not fully recapitulate native membrane characteristics
Redox state considerations:
Post-translational modifications:
Potential modifications in native B. adolescentis may be absent in recombinant systems
Heterologous expression might introduce non-native modifications
Methodological limitations:
In vitro assays often use non-physiological substrate/cofactor concentrations
Detection methods may have different sensitivities
Time scales of measurements may not capture transient interactions
To address these discrepancies, researchers should implement complementary approaches including:
Functional complementation in deletion mutants
Comparison with native protein isolated from B. adolescentis
Systematic variation of assay conditions to identify optimal parameters
Analysis of protein-protein interactions in cellular contexts
The most appropriate statistical approaches for analyzing ATP synthase activity data from recombinant systems include:
Enzyme kinetics models:
Michaelis-Menten kinetics for substrate dependence
Hill equation for systems showing cooperativity
Allosteric models for complex regulatory mechanisms
Nonlinear regression to fit these models to experimental data
Experimental design considerations:
Randomized complete block design to control for batch effects
Factorial designs to examine interaction effects between variables
Response surface methodology to optimize multiple parameters simultaneously
Statistical tests and analyses:
ANOVA for comparing multiple conditions
Mixed-effects models for handling repeated measures
Bootstrapping for robust confidence interval estimation
Bayesian approaches for incorporating prior knowledge
Quality control measures:
Outlier detection using robust statistical methods
Residual analysis to validate model assumptions
Power analysis to determine appropriate sample sizes
Advanced data integration:
Principal component analysis for multivariate data reduction
Hierarchical clustering to identify similar experimental conditions
Machine learning approaches for complex pattern recognition
| Analysis Type | Application | Statistical Method | Software Tools |
|---|---|---|---|
| Enzyme Kinetics | Substrate dependence | Nonlinear regression | GraphPad Prism, R (drc package) |
| Multiple Condition Comparison | Effect of environmental factors | ANOVA, Tukey's HSD | R (stats package), SPSS |
| Time Series | Activity changes over time | Mixed-effects models | R (nlme, lme4 packages) |
| Structure-Function Correlation | Mutant analysis | Multiple regression, PCA | R (stats, FactoMineR packages) |
| Reproducibility Assessment | Technical variation | ICC, Bland-Altman plots | R (psych, BlandAltmanLeh packages) |
When analyzing data specifically related to B. adolescentis ATP synthase, researchers should consider the organism's unique physiological properties, including its response to environmental factors like pH, which has been shown to affect atp operon expression .
Accurately comparing ATP synthase delta subunits across different Bifidobacterium species requires multifaceted approaches:
Studies of related Bifidobacterium species have already identified specific sequence signatures that can distinguish between closely related taxa, such as B. lactis and B. animalis . These approaches can be extended to analyze the ATP synthase delta subunit across different Bifidobacterium species, particularly focusing on species-specific adaptations related to their ecological niches.
Common challenges in purifying recombinant B. adolescentis atpH and their solutions include:
Low expression levels:
Challenge: The atpH gene may express poorly in heterologous systems
Solutions:
Protein insolubility:
Challenge: The delta subunit may form inclusion bodies when expressed alone
Solutions:
Use solubility-enhancing tags (MBP, SUMO, GST)
Lower expression temperature and inducer concentration
Add solubility enhancers to lysis buffer (e.g., sarcosyl, low concentrations of urea)
Co-express with chaperones (GroEL/ES, DnaK/J)
Consider co-expression with interacting ATP synthase subunits
Protein instability:
Challenge: The isolated delta subunit may be unstable without its binding partners
Solutions:
Include protease inhibitors throughout purification
Optimize buffer conditions (pH, salt concentration, glycerol)
Maintain strict temperature control during purification
Consider rapid purification protocols to minimize degradation time
Use ligands or binding partners to stabilize the protein
Contaminant co-purification:
Challenge: Host proteins may co-purify with the recombinant protein
Solutions:
Implement multiple orthogonal purification steps
Use high-stringency washes for affinity chromatography
Consider ion exchange chromatography as a secondary step
Apply size exclusion chromatography as a final polishing step
Use dual affinity tags with orthogonal purification strategies
Low yield in functional form:
Challenge: The protein may purify but lack functional activity
Solutions:
Verify correct folding using circular dichroism
Implement activity assays throughout purification
Consider native-like conditions during expression and purification
Test refolding protocols if necessary
Validate protein-protein interactions with known binding partners
Given that B. adolescentis shows significant changes in membrane potential and redox activity under different environmental conditions , researchers should carefully control buffer conditions, particularly pH and redox state, during purification.
Troubleshooting expression issues with recombinant B. adolescentis atpH requires a systematic approach:
Transcript-level analysis:
Protein expression optimization:
Screen multiple expression hosts and strains
Test various induction conditions (temperature, inducer concentration, time)
Consider auto-induction media for gradual protein expression
Examine cell growth curves to identify potential toxicity issues
Try different media formulations, including varying pH levels
Construct design troubleshooting:
Verify sequence integrity through complete sequencing
Check codon usage and optimize if necessary
Ensure correct reading frame and start/stop codons
Test alternative fusion tags or tag positions (N- vs. C-terminal)
Consider synthetic gene design with optimized parameters
Expression detection methods:
Use Western blotting with tag-specific antibodies
Try different protein extraction methods (native vs. denaturing)
Examine both soluble and insoluble fractions
Consider pulse-chase experiments to track protein fate
Use mass spectrometry for targeted protein identification
Regulatory factors consideration:
Test expression under different pH conditions, given pH-responsive regulation in Bifidobacterium
Examine the impact of oxygen levels on expression
Consider potential repressors or activators that might affect expression
Test for toxicity effects through growth curve analysis
Implement controlled stress conditions that might enhance expression
When troubleshooting, it's important to consider that the atp operon in Bifidobacterium species shows increased transcription in response to acid stress , suggesting that pH manipulation might be a useful strategy for enhancing expression.
Common pitfalls in experimental design for studying recombinant ATP synthase subunits and strategies to avoid them include:
Insufficient consideration of protein-protein interactions:
Pitfall: Studying isolated subunits without their interaction partners
Prevention strategies:
Co-express with interacting subunits
Design experiments that account for complex formation
Validate findings in the context of the complete ATP synthase complex
Use complementation assays in deletion mutants
Inadequate environmental control:
Pitfall: Neglecting the influence of pH, temperature, and redox conditions
Prevention strategies:
Improper activity assay design:
Pitfall: Using assay conditions that don't reflect physiological reality
Prevention strategies:
Validate assay conditions against native enzyme when possible
Include proper controls for background activity
Ensure linear range of detection throughout experiments
Consider the directionality of the ATP synthase reaction (synthesis vs. hydrolysis)
Overlooking post-translational modifications:
Pitfall: Assuming recombinant protein has identical modifications to native protein
Prevention strategies:
Characterize modifications in native protein when possible
Use mass spectrometry to identify differences
Consider expression in more closely related hosts
Implement site-directed mutagenesis to assess the impact of modification sites
Inadequate statistical design:
Pitfall: Insufficient replication or inappropriate statistical methods
Prevention strategies:
Perform power analysis to determine adequate sample sizes
Include biological replicates across independent expressions
Implement appropriate statistical tests for the data structure
Control for batch effects and other sources of variation
Comparative analysis limitations:
Pitfall: Direct comparison of data generated under different conditions
Prevention strategies:
Standardize protocols across compared species or conditions
Include internal standards and controls
Normalize data appropriately for meaningful comparisons
Use statistical methods that account for systematic variation
Research on Bifidobacterium species has shown significant variability in response to environmental conditions , highlighting the importance of controlling these factors in experimental design.
Several emerging research questions regarding B. adolescentis ATP synthase remain to be addressed:
These questions represent opportunities for significant contributions to our understanding of bacterial bioenergetics and the specific adaptations of B. adolescentis to its ecological niche.
Advances in structural biology techniques are poised to revolutionize research on B. adolescentis ATP synthase delta subunit:
Cryo-electron microscopy advancements:
Single-particle cryo-EM now achieves near-atomic resolution for large complexes
Time-resolved cryo-EM can potentially capture different conformational states during the rotary cycle
Subtomogram averaging allows structural studies in cellular contexts
These techniques could reveal the precise position and dynamics of the delta subunit within the ATP synthase complex
Integrative structural biology approaches:
Combining multiple techniques (X-ray crystallography, cryo-EM, NMR, SAXS)
Computational integration of diverse structural data
These approaches can provide comprehensive structural models even when individual techniques face limitations
Mass spectrometry innovations:
Hydrogen-deuterium exchange mass spectrometry (HDX-MS) for dynamics studies
Cross-linking mass spectrometry (XL-MS) for interaction mapping
Native mass spectrometry for intact complex analysis
These techniques can provide insights into protein-protein interactions and conformational changes
Single-molecule techniques:
FRET-based approaches to monitor subunit movements
High-speed AFM to visualize conformational changes
Optical and magnetic tweezers to study mechanical properties
These methods can directly observe the rotary mechanism and force generation
In situ structural biology:
Cryo-electron tomography of cellular preparations
Correlative light and electron microscopy
In-cell NMR spectroscopy
These approaches can study ATP synthase structure in more native environments
These technological advances would be particularly valuable for understanding how the delta subunit of B. adolescentis ATP synthase functions within the complex rotary mechanism, potentially revealing adaptations specific to this organism's ecological niche and metabolic requirements.
Research on recombinant B. adolescentis ATP synthase may lead to several promising biotechnological applications:
Bioenergy applications:
Development of biomimetic energy conversion systems based on ATP synthase principles
Creation of hybrid nanomotors incorporating the robust rotary mechanism
Design of ATP-generating systems for biofuel cells
Engineering of artificial photosynthetic systems with enhanced ATP production
Therapeutic strategies:
Design of novel antibiotics targeting bacterial ATP synthases with structural differences from human counterparts
Development of probiotics with enhanced energy production capabilities
Creation of bacterial delivery systems for therapeutic compounds
Engineering of B. adolescentis strains with modified ATP production for specific gut health applications
Biosensing technologies:
ATP synthase-based biosensors for detecting environmental contaminants
Proton gradient sensors utilizing ATP synthase components
Nanoscale pH sensors based on ATP synthase activity
Detection systems for metabolic disruptors
Nanobiotechnology:
Molecular motors based on the ATP synthase rotary mechanism
Nanodevices powered by ATP hydrolysis
Self-assembling nanomachines utilizing ATP synthase subunit interactions
Biomolecular computing elements utilizing energy conversion principles
Synthetic biology platforms:
Engineered chassis organisms with optimized energy production
Modular bioenergetic systems for synthetic cell designs
Artificial organelles with ATP-generating capabilities
Bioenergetic switches for controlling metabolic networks