CTLA-4 acts as a major negative regulator of T-cell responses by:
Competing with CD28 for B7 ligands, thereby inhibiting T-cell activation .
Trans-endocytosis: Internalizing B7 ligands from antigen-presenting cells (APCs), reducing CD28-mediated co-stimulation .
Regulating Treg cells: Maintaining immune tolerance by suppressing excessive T-cell proliferation .
Recombinant CTLA-4 is produced using:
Prokaryotic systems (E. coli): Cost-effective, high yield, but lacks post-translational modifications (e.g., glycosylation) .
Mammalian systems (HEK 293 or CHO cells): Ensures proper folding and glycosylation, critical for dimerization and ligand binding .
Recent studies challenge the traditional "checkpoint blockade" model:
Mechanism of Anti-CTLA-4 Antibodies: Therapeutic efficacy depends on Fc receptor-mediated Treg depletion rather than direct B7 blockade .
Blocking Activity: Some anti-CTLA-4 antibodies (e.g., 9H10) fail to block B7-CTLA-4 interaction but still induce tumor rejection .
Species-Specific Effects: Humanized Ctla4 mice show differential responses to anti-CTLA-4 antibodies (e.g., L3D10 upregulates B7-2 on DCs) .
Mouse CTLA-4 is typically expressed as a partial recombinant protein including the extracellular domain (ECD). The amino acid sequence for mouse CTLA-4 ECD spans from approximately residue 36 to 162, with the sequence beginning with "EAIQVTQPSVVLASSHGVASFPCEYS..." and ending with "...PPYFVGMGNGTQIYVIDPEPCPDSD" . The protein contains multiple domains including an IgV-like domain that interacts with B7 ligands. N-glycosylation is important for CTLA-4 dimerization . When expressed as a recombinant protein, mouse CTLA-4 is often fused to an Fc region or includes tags like His-tag to facilitate purification and functional studies.
While mouse and human CTLA-4 share significant homology, there are notable differences:
Feature | Mouse CTLA-4 | Human CTLA-4 |
---|---|---|
Amino acid sequence | Starts with "EAIQVTQPS..." | Starts with "AMHVAQPAV..." |
Length (ECD) | Typically aa 36-162 | Typically aa 37-162 |
Binding affinity to B7 ligands | Similar high affinity | Similar high affinity |
Glycosylation pattern | May differ slightly | N-glycosylation critical for function |
Cross-reactivity | Limited cross-reactivity with human ligands | Limited cross-reactivity with mouse ligands |
Despite these differences, both human and mouse CTLA-4 function as inhibitory receptors that negatively regulate T-cell responses . When generating humanized mouse models, special attention must be paid to the exon structure to ensure proper splicing and expression .
CTLA-4 is primarily expressed by:
Activated conventional T cells (upregulated upon activation)
Regulatory T cells (Tregs) (constitutively expressed)
Follicular regulatory T cells (Tfr)
Expression patterns vary by anatomical location. In Tfr cells, CTLA-4 expression correlates with high ICOS expression and increased IRF4 expression, suggesting a functional relationship . CTLA-4 expression is relatively universal in Tfr cells regardless of anatomical location (lymph nodes, circulation, Peyer's patches, skin), although the intensity of expression may vary .
Regulation occurs at multiple levels:
Transcriptionally induced upon T cell activation
Post-translationally regulated through endocytosis and recycling
LRBA-dependent mechanism controls CTLA-4 recycling to cell surface
Lysosomal degradation can be triggered by certain antibodies
For real-time monitoring of CTLA-4 expression and trafficking:
Fluorescent protein tagging: Transfect cells with EGFP-tagged CTLA-4 constructs to visualize trafficking in live cells .
Surface biotinylation assay:
pH-sensitive fluorescent probes: Use pH-sensitive dyes conjugated to anti-CTLA-4 antibodies to distinguish between surface, endosomal, and lysosomal localization.
Flow cytometry approach:
This approach revealed that CTLA-4 downregulation varies with different antibodies - Ipilimumab and TremeIgG1 caused significant downregulation, while other antibodies (HL12, HL32) allowed recycling .
Several robust assays can verify CTLA-4 functional activity:
T cell proliferation/activation inhibition assay:
Binding assays:
Competition assays:
Test the ability of recombinant CTLA-4 to compete with anti-CTLA-4 antibodies
Determine if the protein can block the interaction between CTLA-4 and its ligands
Recombinant CTLA-4 has diverse applications in tumor immunology:
Blocking tumor-induced immunosuppression:
Studying immune checkpoint timing:
Visualizing CTLA-4 distribution:
Understanding mechanism of action:
When selecting or designing anti-CTLA-4 antibodies for research:
Clone selection: Different clones have distinct properties:
Mechanism of action:
Effect on CTLA-4 trafficking:
In vivo effects:
Several approaches for CTLA-4 deficiency models with their advantages and limitations:
Complete knockout models:
Conventional CTLA-4 knockout mice die at 2-3 weeks due to massive lymphoproliferation
Characterized by lymphocytic infiltration and destruction of major organs
T cells show activation markers (CD69, IL-2R), down-regulate CD62L, and proliferate spontaneously
Useful for studying fundamental CTLA-4 biology but limited for long-term studies
Conditional knockout systems:
Partial knockdown models:
Human CTLA-4 knockin models:
When facing inconsistent results:
Protein quality assessment:
Experimental variables to control:
Cell source considerations:
Primary cells vs. cell lines respond differently
Cell activation state affects CTLA-4 expression
Different T cell subsets (conventional T cells vs. Tregs) have different baseline CTLA-4 levels
Assay-specific troubleshooting:
For binding assays: Use proper controls including isotype controls and known CTLA-4 ligands
For functional assays: Include positive controls (anti-CD28) and negative controls
Several approaches can be used to study CTLA-4 function without triggering lethal autoimmunity:
Timing-controlled CTLA-4 deletion:
Partial CTLA-4 inhibition:
Blocking B7-CTLA-4 interactions:
Cell-specific CTLA-4 manipulation:
Combination approaches:
For optimal recombinant mouse CTLA-4 production:
Expression systems:
Construct design:
Include extracellular domain (typically aa 36-162 for mouse CTLA-4)
Consider fusion partners:
Fc tag for dimerization and purification
His-tag for affinity purification
Fluorescent protein tags for tracking studies
Purification strategy:
Quality control:
For investigating CTLA-4 signaling:
Phosphorylation studies:
Western blot analysis of key CTLA-4 downstream signals
Phospho-specific antibodies to detect activation of pathways
Immunoprecipitation to isolate CTLA-4 complexes
Genetic approaches:
Biochemical techniques:
Pull-down assays to identify interaction partners
Mass spectrometry to identify novel binding partners
In vitro kinase assays to assess phosphorylation events
Imaging approaches:
Confocal microscopy to visualize CTLA-4 clustering with signaling components
FRET/BRET to detect protein-protein interactions
Live cell imaging using fluorescently tagged proteins
Functional readouts:
Multiplex cytokine analysis
Transcriptomic analysis following CTLA-4 engagement
Cell proliferation and survival assays
Calcium flux measurements