ATP-binding (A) component of a common energy-coupling factor (ECF) ABC-transporter complex. Unlike classic ABC transporters, this ECF transporter provides the energy for the transport of various substrates.
KEGG: mmy:MSC_0717
STRING: 272632.MSC_0717
EcfA1 (Energy-coupling factor transporter ATP-binding protein A1) is a critical component of ECF transporters in Mycoplasma mycoides subsp. mycoides SC, the causative agent of contagious bovine pleuropneumonia (CBPP). It functions as an ATP-binding protein that provides energy for the transport of essential micronutrients across the bacterial membrane. EcfA1 belongs to the larger family of ATP-binding cassette (ABC) transporters and specifically works within the ECF transporter complex to enable the uptake of vitamins and trace elements that are essential for bacterial survival and virulence . The protein contains characteristic Walker A and Walker B motifs typical of ATP-binding proteins, allowing it to hydrolyze ATP and power the conformational changes necessary for substrate transport across the membrane.
To identify EcfA1 in the M. mycoides SC proteome, you should follow a systematic approach similar to that described for surface protein identification. Begin by retrieving the complete genome sequence of M. mycoides SC strain PG1 from databases such as EMBL/GenBank/DDBJ (entry BX293980). Then, analyze the proteome using bioinformatics tools such as SignalP to identify signal peptide sequences, followed by TMHMM for transmembrane region prediction . For EcfA1 specifically, you would search for ATP-binding motifs characteristic of ABC transporters. BLASTP analysis can help assess similarity to proteins in other species . The ecfA1 gene in M. mycoides SC would typically be identified by its conserved domains, including the Walker A (P-loop) and Walker B motifs that are characteristic of ATP-binding proteins involved in energy-dependent transport systems.
The EcfA1 protein from M. mycoides SC contains several key structural features typical of ATP-binding components of ECF transporters:
Walker A motif (P-loop): A conserved sequence (GXXGXGKT/S) involved in ATP binding
Walker B motif: A conserved sequence involved in ATP hydrolysis
Q-loop: Involved in interactions with the transmembrane domain
H-loop: Important for the catalytic mechanism
Signature motif: Specific to ABC transporters, involved in ATP binding and hydrolysis
When designing recombinant proteins, these structural features should be preserved for functional studies. Similar to other recombinant M. mycoides SC proteins, EcfA1 can be designed to exclude signal peptides and transmembrane regions that may affect protein expression while preserving the functional domains . The amino acid coverage should be optimized to ensure structural resemblance to the native protein while enabling efficient expression in E. coli or other expression systems.
One of the critical challenges in expressing M. mycoides SC proteins in E. coli is addressing the TGA codon issue. In Mycoplasma, TGA encodes tryptophan rather than serving as a stop codon as it does in E. coli. To express EcfA1 in E. coli, you must convert all TGA codons to TGG, which universally encodes tryptophan .
The most efficient approach is to use a multiple mutation reaction method adapted for high throughput substitution. This involves:
First, count the number of TGA codons in your ecfA1 gene sequence to determine the extent of mutagenesis required
Design a two-step PCR process: first performing a multiple mutation reaction using a sequence-verified plasmid as template with Pfx50 and Ampligase enzymes
Follow with a secondary PCR to introduce a biotin, enabling solid phase restriction and religation into an expression vector (e.g., pAff8c)
Transform E. coli BL21(DE3), induce expression with isopropyl 1-thio-β-d-galactopyranoside, and harvest cells for protein purification
The multiple mutation reaction method allows simultaneous substitution of up to five codons, though the actual limit might be higher based on sequencing results from approximately six colonies per reaction .
The optimal strategy for cloning and expressing recombinant EcfA1 from M. mycoides SC follows a methodical approach:
Source material: Extract whole genomic DNA from M. mycoides SC strain (preferably M223/90 or similar well-characterized strain)
Codon modification: Identify and mutate all TGA codons to TGG to enable expression in E. coli
Expression vector selection: Use a vector like pAff8c that provides an N-terminal fusion tag
Design considerations:
Expression system: Transform E. coli BL21(DE3) with the verified construct
Induction and harvesting: Induce with isopropyl 1-thio-β-d-galactopyranoside, harvest cells, and lyse them for protein extraction
Purification: Use immobilized metal ion chromatography (IMAC) to obtain purified recombinant EcfA1
This approach has been successful for other M. mycoides SC proteins and should be adaptable for EcfA1, with protein-specific optimizations as needed for expression and solubility.
To assess the quality and purity of recombinant EcfA1, employ a multi-method approach:
SDS-PAGE analysis: Run 1.5 μg of purified protein on a 15% Tris/HCl gel to assess purity and molecular weight
Western blotting: Transfer the separated proteins to a nitrocellulose membrane and probe with:
Mass spectrometry: Perform peptide mass fingerprinting to confirm protein identity
Functional assays: Assess ATP binding and hydrolysis capabilities using:
ATP-binding assays with radiolabeled ATP
Colorimetric ATPase activity assays
For Western blotting specifically, block the membrane, incubate with 1:5000 dilution of preblocked sera, and detect bound antibodies with secondary goat anti-bovine IgG conjugated with horseradish peroxidase (4 ng/ml) .
Analyzing EcfA1 interactions with other ECF transporter components requires specialized techniques:
Co-immunoprecipitation (Co-IP):
Express recombinant EcfA1 and potential interaction partners with different tags
Use anti-tag antibodies to pull down EcfA1 and identify co-precipitated proteins
Western blot or mass spectrometry can confirm the identity of interaction partners
Surface Plasmon Resonance (SPR):
Immobilize purified EcfA1 on a sensor chip
Flow potential interaction partners over the chip
Measure binding kinetics and affinity constants
Bead-based multiplex assay:
In vitro reconstitution assays:
Purify all components of the ECF transporter complex
Reconstitute in liposomes or nanodiscs
Measure transport activity with labeled substrates
These methods can be complementary, providing a comprehensive analysis of protein-protein interactions within the ECF transporter complex.
When analyzing antibody binding data for EcfA1 in serological assays, follow these methodological steps:
Initial data quality assessment:
For bead-based multiplex assays:
Establish a baseline by testing sera from negative controls (e.g., Swedish negative controls for CBPP studies)
Set a signal cutoff threshold that allows clear separation between positive and negative samples (aim for at least 20-fold mean signal separation as achieved with M. mycoides SC proteins)
Confirm protein specificity through inhibition experiments
Validate results by comparing with established methods like Western blot
Statistical analysis:
Data visualization:
This structured approach enables reliable interpretation of antibody binding data for EcfA1 and comparison with other M. mycoides SC proteins.
The most appropriate statistical methods for analyzing EcfA1 functional data depend on the experimental design and data characteristics:
For ATP hydrolysis kinetics:
Michaelis-Menten kinetic analysis to determine Km and Vmax parameters
Non-linear regression analysis for fitting enzyme kinetic models
ANOVA to compare kinetic parameters across different experimental conditions
For comparative protein activity:
For time-course experiments:
Repeated measures ANOVA to assess changes over time
Mixed-effects models to account for both fixed and random effects
Quality control for experimental data:
Each analysis should include appropriate data visualization (scatter plots, bar graphs, or box plots) to facilitate interpretation and communication of results.
Integrating EcfA1 data with broader proteomics findings requires a systematic approach:
Data harmonization and preprocessing:
Multi-omics integration strategies:
Correlation analysis between EcfA1 expression/activity and other proteins
Network analysis to place EcfA1 within protein-protein interaction networks
Pathway enrichment analysis to understand functional relationships
Statistical modeling approaches:
Comparative analysis with vaccine studies:
Visualization and interpretation:
Create comprehensive visualizations that integrate multiple data types
Interpret findings in the context of known pathogenicity mechanisms
Draw connections between EcfA1 function and virulence of M. mycoides SC
This integrated approach helps position EcfA1 within the broader context of M. mycoides SC pathogenicity and potential vaccine development.
EcfA1 has potential as a diagnostic marker for CBPP, which can be explored through these methodological approaches:
Development of EcfA1-based serological assays:
Express recombinant EcfA1 with an N-terminal His₆ABP tag as described for other M. mycoides SC proteins
Couple purified EcfA1 to carboxylated magnetic beads using 1-ethyl-3(3-dimethylamino-propyl)carbodiimide and N-hydroxysuccinimide chemistry
Optimize the assay using known CBPP-positive sera (e.g., Namibian CBPP-positive samples) and negative controls
Aim for at least 20-fold mean signal separation between positive and negative samples, similar to what was achieved with other M. mycoides SC proteins
Validation of diagnostic specificity and sensitivity:
Test the assay on a large panel of sera from CBPP-affected and healthy cattle
Calculate sensitivity, specificity, positive predictive value, and negative predictive value
Compare with existing diagnostic tests for CBPP
Multiplex diagnostic applications:
Field testing and implementation:
Evaluate assay performance under field conditions in CBPP-endemic regions
Assess the stability of EcfA1-coupled beads for long-term storage and field use
Develop standardized protocols for sample collection and testing
The diagnostic value of EcfA1 would need to be compared with established M. mycoides SC diagnostic antigens to determine its unique contribution to CBPP diagnosis.
Developing inhibitors against EcfA1 presents several distinct challenges:
Structural considerations:
Limited structural information about mycoplasma EcfA1 proteins compared to other bacterial ATP-binding proteins
Need for high-resolution crystal structures or cryo-EM data to guide rational inhibitor design
Challenges in expressing and purifying sufficient quantities of properly folded protein for structural studies
Assay development for inhibitor screening:
Establishing robust ATPase activity assays for high-throughput screening
Developing whole-cell assays that specifically measure EcfA1 function
Ensuring assay specificity to distinguish EcfA1 inhibition from effects on other ATP-binding proteins
Selectivity challenges:
Designing inhibitors that target mycoplasma EcfA1 without affecting host ATP-binding proteins
Achieving specificity for EcfA1 over other bacterial ATP-binding proteins
Balancing potency with selectivity to minimize off-target effects
Drug delivery considerations:
Developing compounds that can penetrate the unique cell membrane of mycoplasmas
Achieving adequate bioavailability in infected lung tissue for CBPP treatment
Addressing potential resistance mechanisms
Testing inhibitor efficacy:
Developing appropriate in vitro and in vivo models for CBPP
Establishing correlations between EcfA1 inhibition and reduction in bacterial viability
Validating therapeutic potential in animal models of CBPP
These challenges must be systematically addressed through iterative experimental approaches and interdisciplinary collaboration between structural biologists, medicinal chemists, and veterinary scientists.
A comprehensive functional comparison of EcfA1 across pathogenic Mycoplasma species requires:
Comparative sequence analysis:
Identify homologous EcfA1 proteins in other Mycoplasma species through BLASTP searches
Perform multiple sequence alignments to identify conserved functional domains and species-specific variations
Use phylogenetic analysis to establish evolutionary relationships
Structural comparison:
Model the 3D structures of EcfA1 proteins from different species using homology modeling
Compare ATP-binding sites and interaction interfaces
Identify structural features that might confer species-specific functionalities
Experimental functional comparison:
Express and purify recombinant EcfA1 proteins from multiple Mycoplasma species
Compare biochemical properties including:
ATP binding affinity (Kd)
ATP hydrolysis kinetics (Km and kcat values)
Thermal stability and pH optima
Assess interactions with other ECF transporter components across species
Role in pathogenicity:
Compare immunoreactivity of EcfA1 from different species using sera from infected animals
Assess contribution to nutrient acquisition in different host environments
Evaluate genetic conservation across clinical isolates of each species
This comparative approach would provide insights into the evolution of ECF transporters in Mycoplasma and might identify species-specific adaptations related to host specificity and pathogenicity.
The detailed protocol for coupling recombinant EcfA1 to magnetic beads follows these specific steps:
Materials preparation:
Carboxylated magnetic beads (MagPlex-C, Luminex Corp.)
Purified recombinant EcfA1 protein (100 μg/ml)
Coupling buffer (0.1 M NaH₂PO₄, pH 6.2)
Activation reagents: 1-ethyl-3(3-dimethylamino-propyl)carbodiimide and N-hydroxysuccinimide (50 μg/ml each)
96-well plate (Greiner Bio-One)
Magnet (e.g., Lifesept, Dexter Magnetic Technologies)
Thermomixer (Eppendorf)
Low binding microcentrifuge tubes (Starlab)
Storage buffer (blocking reagent for ELISA containing 0.5% NaN₃)
Ultrasonic cleaner (e.g., Branson Ultrasonic Corp.)
Bead activation procedure:
Transfer 10⁶ beads per ID to separate wells in a 96-well plate
Sediment beads using the magnet and wash once with coupling buffer
Resuspend beads in coupling buffer
Add 10 μl of 1-ethyl-3(3-dimethylamino-propyl)carbodiimide (50 μg/ml) and 10 μl of N-hydroxysuccinimide (50 μg/ml)
Incubate for exactly 20 minutes on a shaker at room temperature
Protein coupling:
Storage and preparation for use:
This protocol has been successfully applied to other M. mycoides SC proteins and should work effectively for EcfA1 with possible minor optimizations if needed.
When facing low expression yields of recombinant EcfA1, systematically address potential issues:
Codon optimization issues:
Protein solubility problems:
Modify the fusion tag strategy (the His₆ABP tag has proven effective for other M. mycoides SC proteins)
Adjust the protein design to exclude problematic regions:
Further truncate transmembrane regions if present
Consider expressing functional domains separately
Try expression at lower temperatures (16-20°C) to enhance proper folding
Expression conditions optimization:
Test different E. coli strains (BL21(DE3), Rosetta, Arctic Express)
Optimize induction parameters:
IPTG concentration (0.1-1.0 mM range)
Induction time (2-24 hours)
Induction OD₆₀₀ (0.4-0.8)
Try auto-induction media instead of IPTG induction
Protein toxicity mitigation:
Use tightly controlled expression systems to minimize leaky expression
Try E. coli strains with additional rare tRNA genes if codon bias is an issue
Use glucose to suppress basal expression from lac-based promoters
Purification strategy adjustments:
Optimize lysis conditions to maximize protein extraction
Try different IMAC conditions (imidazole concentration, pH)
Consider on-column refolding during purification if inclusion bodies form
This systematic troubleshooting approach has been successful for expressing challenging M. mycoides SC proteins and can be adapted specifically for EcfA1 .
The best approaches for studying ATP hydrolysis activity of purified EcfA1 include:
Colorimetric phosphate detection assays:
Malachite green assay: Detects inorganic phosphate released during ATP hydrolysis
NADH-coupled assay: Links ATP hydrolysis to NADH oxidation for continuous monitoring
EnzChek Phosphate Assay: Uses purine nucleoside phosphorylase to convert MESG substrate to a product with absorbance at 360 nm
Experimental setup:
Buffer optimization: Typically 50 mM Tris-HCl pH 7.5, 150 mM NaCl, 5 mM MgCl₂
ATP concentration series (0.1-5 mM) to determine Km and Vmax
Temperature optimization (25-37°C)
Various divalent cations (Mg²⁺, Mn²⁺, Ca²⁺) to determine cofactor preference
Data collection and analysis:
Initial velocity measurements in the linear range
Michaelis-Menten kinetic analysis to determine Km and Vmax
Hill coefficient calculation to assess cooperativity
Inhibition studies with ADP, non-hydrolyzable ATP analogs, or potential inhibitors
Validation experiments:
Site-directed mutagenesis of Walker A and B motifs as negative controls
Comparison with other ATP-binding proteins as positive controls
Activity in the presence of other ECF transporter components to assess complex formation effects
Advanced analysis techniques:
Isothermal titration calorimetry (ITC) to measure binding thermodynamics
³²P-ATP hydrolysis assays for increased sensitivity
Pre-steady-state kinetics using rapid mixing techniques to identify reaction intermediates
These methodological approaches provide complementary data on EcfA1's ATPase activity, crucial for understanding its role in the ECF transporter complex.
EcfA1 research can contribute to CBPP vaccine development through several methodological approaches:
Antigenicity and immunogenicity assessment:
Comparative immunological profiling:
Subunit vaccine development:
Assess EcfA1 as a potential subunit vaccine candidate alone or in combination with other antigens
Design EcfA1-based constructs optimized for immunogenicity:
Full-length protein excluding transmembrane regions
Immunodominant epitopes identified through epitope mapping
Fusion with adjuvant molecules to enhance immunogenicity
Vaccine efficacy testing protocol:
Rational vaccine design approach:
Use structural information about EcfA1 to design improved antigens
Target conserved, surface-exposed regions of EcfA1 that are essential for function
Develop combination vaccines targeting multiple components of nutrient acquisition systems
This systematic approach leverages established methodologies for M. mycoides SC surface proteins to evaluate EcfA1's potential contribution to next-generation CBPP vaccines.
Emerging research directions for studying EcfA1 and related transporters include:
Structural biology approaches:
Cryo-electron microscopy to determine the structure of complete ECF transporter complexes
X-ray crystallography of EcfA1 in different nucleotide-bound states
Hydrogen-deuterium exchange mass spectrometry to map conformational changes during the transport cycle
System-level studies:
Transcriptomics to understand ecfA1 expression regulation under different conditions
Metabolomics to identify substrates transported by ECF transporters containing EcfA1
Interactomics to map the complete interaction network of EcfA1 within M. mycoides SC
Advanced functional characterization:
Single-molecule techniques to observe EcfA1 function in real-time
Nanodiscs or liposome reconstitution to study transport in a membrane environment
Microfluidics approaches for high-throughput functional screening
Comparative genomics and evolution:
Analysis of EcfA1 conservation and variation across Mycoplasma species
Investigation of horizontal gene transfer events involving ecfA1
Evolutionary adaptation of EcfA1 to different host environments
Therapeutic targeting strategies:
Fragment-based drug discovery for EcfA1 inhibitors
Peptide inhibitors designed to disrupt EcfA1 interactions with other transporter components
PROTAC (proteolysis targeting chimera) approaches for selective degradation
These emerging directions leverage cutting-edge technologies to advance our understanding of EcfA1 function and its potential as a therapeutic target or vaccine candidate.
Computational approaches can significantly enhance EcfA1 research through:
Structural prediction and analysis:
Homology modeling to predict EcfA1 structure based on related ATP-binding proteins
Molecular dynamics simulations to study:
Conformational changes during ATP binding and hydrolysis
Interactions with other ECF transporter components
Effects of mutations on protein stability and function
Binding site prediction to identify potential inhibitor binding pockets
Network-based analyses:
Protein-protein interaction network construction to position EcfA1 in the cellular context
Metabolic network analysis to understand the impact of EcfA1 function on M. mycoides SC metabolism
Gene co-expression networks to identify functionally related genes
Machine learning applications:
Prediction of antibody epitopes on EcfA1 for vaccine design
Classification of ATP-binding site variations across species
Feature extraction from experimental data to identify patterns not obvious through conventional analysis
Virtual screening and drug design:
Structure-based virtual screening for potential EcfA1 inhibitors
Pharmacophore modeling based on ATP binding site
Molecular docking studies to predict binding modes of potential inhibitors
Data integration frameworks:
Integration of diverse experimental data (proteomics, genomics, structural data)
Mathematical modeling of ECF transporter function
Development of predictive models for EcfA1 activity under different conditions
These computational approaches complement experimental methods and can accelerate EcfA1 research by generating testable hypotheses and providing mechanistic insights that might be challenging to obtain experimentally.