F1F0 ATP synthase synthesizes ATP from ADP using a proton or sodium gradient. This enzyme comprises two domains: F1, the extramembrane catalytic core; and F0, the membrane proton channel. These are linked by a central and peripheral stalk. ATP synthesis in the F1 catalytic domain is coupled to proton translocation via a rotary mechanism involving the central stalk subunits. This protein is a component of the F0 channel, forming part of the peripheral stalk that connects F1 and F0.
KEGG: npu:Npun_F4861
STRING: 63737.Npun_F4861
ATP synthase subunit b (atpF) in Nostoc punctiforme is a critical component of the ATP synthase complex, essential for energy metabolism in this filamentous cyanobacterium . It is a 190-amino acid protein encoded by the atpF gene (locus name: Npun_F4861) in Nostoc punctiforme strain ATCC 29133 / PCC 73102 . The protein is also known by several alternative names including ATP synthase F(0) sector subunit b, ATPase subunit I, F-type ATPase subunit b, and F-ATPase subunit b . The full amino acid sequence of this protein is: MGIMGTFLLLAAEANAVHSELAEGAAEGGFGLNLDIFETNLINLAILVGILFYFGRKV LSNILNERQSNIATAIQEAEGRLKEAKTALSQAQEQLKQSQAEAERIRQSAVENAQKA KEALLAKAVQDVERLKQTAAADLNTETERAIAQLRQRVATLALQKVESQLKGGIADDA QQSLIDRSIAQLGGNV .
Proper storage and handling of recombinant Nostoc punctiforme ATP synthase subunit b is crucial for maintaining protein integrity and experimental reproducibility. The protein is typically stored in a Tris-based buffer with 50% glycerol, optimized specifically for this protein . For long-term storage, it should be kept at -20°C or -80°C for extended preservation . Working aliquots can be stored at 4°C for up to one week to minimize freeze-thaw cycles . Repeated freezing and thawing is not recommended as it can lead to protein degradation and loss of functional activity . Researchers should create small working aliquots upon initial thawing to prevent unnecessary freeze-thaw cycles that might compromise experimental outcomes.
While the search results don't explicitly detail expression systems for this specific protein, recombinant proteins from cyanobacterial sources like Nostoc punctiforme are typically produced using either prokaryotic (E. coli) or eukaryotic expression systems depending on the experimental requirements. For functional studies of ATP synthase components, E. coli expression systems are commonly employed due to their efficiency and cost-effectiveness. The recombinant protein described in the search results appears to be the full-length protein (expression region 1-190) , suggesting an expression system capable of producing the complete functional unit. The tag type for purification purposes is determined during the production process and may vary based on specific experimental needs .
ATP synthase, including subunit b, plays a crucial role in Nostoc punctiforme's adaptation to various environmental conditions. This cyanobacterium can differentiate into three distinct cell types in response to environmental cues: nitrogen-fixing heterocysts, spore-like akinetes, and motile hormogonium filaments . In nitrogen-deficient conditions, ATP synthase is one of the most abundant proteins expressed alongside superoxide dismutase and peptidyl-prolyl cis-trans isomerases , highlighting its importance in energy metabolism during nitrogen fixation. The regulation of ATP synthase genes differs across developmental states - many genes for energy metabolism, including ATP synthase, are down-regulated during hormogonium formation , suggesting a metabolic shift during this motile phase. ATP levels do not vary significantly between wild-type and zwf mutant strains during dark incubation, indicating that factors beyond simple energy levels may regulate developmental processes like akinete formation .
For elucidating structure-function relationships of recombinant Nostoc punctiforme ATP synthase subunit b, multiple complementary approaches should be employed. X-ray crystallography or cryo-electron microscopy can provide high-resolution structural data, while functional assays using purified recombinant protein can assess ATP synthesis/hydrolysis activities. Site-directed mutagenesis targeting specific amino acid residues (particularly in the transmembrane regions identified in the sequence NLINLAILVGILFYFGRKVLS) can reveal critical functional domains . Protein-protein interaction studies using techniques such as co-immunoprecipitation, crosslinking, or yeast two-hybrid assays can identify binding partners within the ATP synthase complex. Circular dichroism spectroscopy can characterize secondary structural elements and their changes in different conditions. For in vivo functional studies, gene knockout/complementation experiments in N. punctiforme can assess the physiological importance of specific protein regions. Using ELISA-based approaches with the recombinant protein can also help study interaction kinetics with other components of the ATP synthase complex .
The expression pattern of ATP synthase components, including subunit b, varies significantly across Nostoc punctiforme's developmental stages. Global gene expression analysis using DNA microarrays has revealed that genes encoding ATP synthase and other energy metabolism proteins are differentially regulated during the formation of heterocysts, akinetes, and hormogonia . During hormogonium formation, many energy metabolism genes, including those for ATP synthase, are down-regulated, consistent with entry into a non-growth state . To effectively capture these expression differences, researchers should employ:
Time-course transcriptomics using RNA-Seq or microarrays to track expression changes during differentiation
Proteomics approaches to correlate transcript levels with protein abundance
Reporter gene fusions (similar to those used for the akinete marker gene avaK ) to visualize expression in situ
Cell-type specific isolation techniques followed by molecular analysis
Comparative studies between wild-type and developmental mutants (like the zwf mutant )
For controlled experimental conditions, researchers can induce specific developmental states: nitrogen deprivation for heterocyst formation, dark incubation with fructose for akinete-like cells (particularly in zwf mutants ), and various environmental triggers for hormogonium formation.
The relationship between ATP synthase activity and cellular differentiation in Nostoc punctiforme appears complex. During differentiation into different cell types, significant metabolic reprogramming occurs, affecting energy production pathways. For instance, ATP levels do not vary significantly between wild-type and zwf mutant strains during dark incubation, even though the latter forms akinete-like cells while the former continues heterotrophic growth . This suggests that signals beyond simple energy status may trigger differentiation.
To experimentally investigate this relationship, researchers could:
Measure ATP synthase activity in isolated cell types using biochemical assays
Create conditional mutants of ATP synthase components to observe effects on differentiation
Use metabolic inhibitors targeting ATP synthase to assess differentiation outcomes
Perform metabolomic analyses across developmental stages to track energy metabolite pools
Combine microscopy techniques with fluorescent ATP sensors to visualize ATP distribution in differentiating filaments
Compare transcriptomic data on ATP synthase genes with morphological changes during differentiation
The zwf mutant system provides a valuable experimental model, as it forms synchronized akinete-like cells upon dark incubation with fructose , allowing researchers to study the temporal relationship between ATP synthase expression/activity and developmental progression.
For effective structural studies of recombinant Nostoc punctiforme ATP synthase subunit b, researchers should consider several approaches and potential challenges:
Methodological Approaches:
Potential Challenges:
Protein solubility issues due to transmembrane regions (e.g., "NLINLAILVGILFYFGRKVLS" sequence )
Maintaining native conformation outside the membrane environment
Stability concerns during purification and crystallization
Potential for aggregation due to hydrophobic domains
Need for appropriate detergents or lipid nanodisc systems to mimic the native membrane environment
Researchers should carefully optimize buffer conditions (currently using Tris-based buffer with 50% glycerol ), consider fusion tags to enhance solubility while maintaining function, and explore reconstitution into artificial membrane systems to preserve native conformation.
When designing functional assays with recombinant Nostoc punctiforme ATP synthase subunit b, several essential controls should be incorporated:
Positive Controls:
Well-characterized ATP synthase subunits from model organisms (e.g., E. coli) with known activity profiles
Native ATP synthase complex isolated from Nostoc punctiforme
Synthetic peptides corresponding to known functional domains
Negative Controls:
Denatured recombinant protein (heat-treated)
Buffer-only samples without protein
Recombinant protein with mutations in critical functional residues
Recombinant protein treated with specific inhibitors of ATP synthase
Specificity Controls:
Other subunits of the ATP synthase complex to confirm subunit-specific effects
Homologous proteins from related cyanobacterial species
Recombinant protein with different tags to rule out tag interference
Additionally, researchers should perform dose-response experiments, time-course studies, and validation using alternative assay methods. When investigating protein-protein interactions, competing peptides or antibodies can serve as useful controls to confirm binding specificity.
Optimizing expression and purification of recombinant Nostoc punctiforme ATP synthase subunit b requires addressing its membrane-associated nature and ensuring proper folding. The following optimization strategies are recommended:
Expression System Selection:
E. coli strains specialized for membrane proteins (e.g., C41/C43)
Cell-free expression systems that can incorporate detergents or lipids
Consideration of codon optimization for the host organism
Expression Conditions Optimization:
Induction temperature (typically lower temperatures for membrane proteins)
Inducer concentration and induction timing
Media composition, including potential membrane-stabilizing additives
Protein Extraction and Solubilization:
Detergent screening (mild non-ionic detergents often preferred)
Lipid nanodisc incorporation for native-like environment
Careful cell lysis to prevent aggregation
Purification Strategy:
Affinity chromatography using appropriate tags (determined during production process )
Size exclusion chromatography to ensure monodispersity
Ion exchange chromatography for final polishing
Stability Enhancement:
Optimization of buffer components beyond the standard Tris-based buffer with 50% glycerol
Addition of specific lipids that might be required for stability
Storage in small aliquots at -20°C or -80°C to prevent freeze-thaw damage
Quality Control Assessments:
SDS-PAGE and Western blotting for purity verification
Mass spectrometry for sequence confirmation
Circular dichroism to confirm proper secondary structure
Dynamic light scattering for aggregation assessment
Several complementary approaches can be employed to study interactions between ATP synthase subunit b and other components of the ATP synthase complex in Nostoc punctiforme:
In vitro Interaction Studies:
Co-immunoprecipitation using antibodies against recombinant ATP synthase subunit b
Pull-down assays using tagged recombinant protein
Surface plasmon resonance to measure binding kinetics
Isothermal titration calorimetry for thermodynamic parameters
Chemical cross-linking followed by mass spectrometry to identify interaction sites
Structural Studies of Interactions:
Cryo-electron microscopy of reconstituted complexes
X-ray crystallography of co-crystallized components
Hydrogen-deuterium exchange mass spectrometry to identify binding interfaces
NMR for studying dynamics of interactions
In vivo Interaction Studies:
Förster resonance energy transfer (FRET) with fluorescently tagged subunits
Split-GFP complementation assays
Bacterial two-hybrid systems
In vivo cross-linking followed by co-purification
Computational Approaches:
Molecular docking simulations using the known amino acid sequence
Molecular dynamics to study stability of predicted interactions
Co-evolution analysis to identify potentially interacting residues
These methods can be particularly informative when applied across different developmental stages of Nostoc punctiforme to understand how complex assembly might change during heterocyst, akinete, or hormogonium formation.
When analyzing data related to ATP synthase activity across different Nostoc punctiforme cell types, researchers should employ statistical approaches that account for biological variability and experimental design complexities:
For Comparing Activity Across Cell Types:
Analysis of Variance (ANOVA) followed by appropriate post-hoc tests (e.g., Tukey's HSD) for comparing multiple cell types
Mixed-effects models to account for both fixed effects (cell type) and random effects (biological replicates, experimental batches)
Non-parametric alternatives (Kruskal-Wallis, Mann-Whitney U) if normality assumptions are violated
For Time-Course Experiments:
Repeated measures ANOVA or mixed-effects models with time as a factor
Time series analysis to identify patterns and correlations over developmental progression
Regression models to quantify relationships between ATP synthase activity and developmental markers
For Multivariate Datasets:
Principal Component Analysis or Factor Analysis to identify patterns across multiple variables
Canonical Correlation Analysis to relate ATP synthase metrics to other physiological parameters
Hierarchical clustering to identify groups of samples with similar profiles
For Gene Expression Data:
Differential expression analysis using tools like DESeq2 or edgeR
Gene Set Enrichment Analysis to place ATP synthase genes in broader functional contexts
Co-expression network analysis to identify genes with similar expression patterns
Researchers should also consider:
Setting appropriate significance thresholds with correction for multiple testing
Calculating effect sizes alongside p-values
Performing power analyses to ensure adequate sample sizes
Using visualization techniques (e.g., box plots with individual data points, heat maps) to effectively communicate results
Distinguishing direct effects on ATP synthase function from indirect metabolic consequences in Nostoc punctiforme mutants requires a multi-faceted experimental approach:
Direct Assessment Strategies:
In vitro ATP synthase activity assays with purified enzyme complexes from mutant and wild-type strains
Site-directed mutagenesis targeting specific ATP synthase components vs. other metabolic enzymes
Protein-protein interaction studies to assess complex assembly in mutants
Structural analysis of ATP synthase components from mutant strains
Metabolic Profiling Approaches:
Comprehensive metabolomics to identify broader metabolic changes
Isotope labeling experiments to track carbon and nitrogen flux through metabolic pathways
Real-time monitoring of ATP/ADP ratios and proton gradients in living cells
Respirometry and photosynthetic activity measurements
Genetic Complementation Tests:
Rescue experiments with wild-type ATP synthase genes in mutant backgrounds
Construction of double mutants affecting both ATP synthase and other metabolic pathways
Controlled expression systems (inducible promoters) to modulate ATP synthase component levels
Temporal Analysis:
Time-course experiments to determine primary vs. secondary effects
Acute vs. chronic inhibition studies using chemical inhibitors of ATP synthase
The zwf mutant system in Nostoc punctiforme provides an instructive example: while lacking glucose-6-phosphate dehydrogenase (the initial enzyme of the oxidative pentose phosphate pathway), it shows no significant differences in ATP levels compared to wild-type during dark incubation, despite profound differences in developmental outcomes . This suggests that developmental triggers may not be directly related to absolute ATP levels. Such analyses help researchers separate direct effects on ATP synthase from broader metabolic consequences of mutations.
For comprehensive analysis of Nostoc punctiforme ATP synthase subunit b structure and function, researchers should utilize various bioinformatic tools and databases:
Sequence Analysis Tools:
UniProt (the protein is cataloged as B2J056 ) for curated sequence information and functional annotations
BLASTP for identifying homologs across species
Clustal Omega or MUSCLE for multiple sequence alignments
HMMER for profile-based searches to identify distant homologs
Structural Prediction Tools:
AlphaFold or RoseTTAFold for protein structure prediction
SWISS-MODEL for homology modeling
TMpred or TMHMM for transmembrane domain prediction (important for the identified transmembrane regions )
PredictProtein for secondary structure and functional site prediction
Functional Analysis Resources:
Pfam for protein domain identification
ConSurf for evolutionary conservation analysis to identify functionally important residues
STRING for protein-protein interaction network analysis
KEGG for metabolic pathway mapping
Cyanobacteria-Specific Resources:
CyanoBase for genomic context and comparative genomics
JGI Genome Portal for Nostoc punctiforme ATCC 29133 genomic data
Cyanomics for transcriptomic data from various conditions
Integrated Analysis Platforms:
InterPro for integrated protein sequence analysis
NCBI Conserved Domains for identifying functional domains
I-TASSER for combined structure and function prediction
Phyre2 for fold recognition and structure prediction
Using these resources, researchers can gain insights into the evolutionary conservation of ATP synthase subunit b, predict its structure, identify potential functional sites, and place it in the context of ATP synthase complex assembly and function across different cyanobacterial species.
Working with recombinant Nostoc punctiforme ATP synthase subunit b presents several technical challenges due to its membrane-associated nature. Here are common issues and their solutions:
Protein Solubility Issues:
Challenge: The hydrophobic transmembrane regions (e.g., "NLINLAILVGILFYFGRKVLS" ) can cause aggregation.
Solutions: (1) Use appropriate detergents for extraction and purification; (2) Consider protein fusion tags that enhance solubility; (3) Optimize buffer conditions beyond the standard Tris-based buffer with 50% glycerol ; (4) Employ membrane mimetics like nanodiscs or liposomes.
Protein Stability Concerns:
Challenge: Recombinant membrane proteins often show reduced stability outside their native environment.
Solutions: (1) Store at -20°C or -80°C for extended periods ; (2) Prepare small working aliquots to avoid freeze-thaw cycles ; (3) Include stabilizing agents like glycerol (currently used at 50% ); (4) Consider addition of specific lipids that might enhance stability.
Functional Activity Assessment:
Challenge: Maintaining native activity in isolation from the complete ATP synthase complex.
Solutions: (1) Reconstitute with other ATP synthase components; (2) Design assays that measure specific aspects of subunit b function rather than complete ATP synthesis; (3) Use liposome reconstitution systems to provide a membrane environment.
Protein-Protein Interaction Studies:
Challenge: Weak or transient interactions may be difficult to detect.
Solutions: (1) Use chemical crosslinking to stabilize interactions; (2) Employ techniques sensitive to weak interactions like biolayer interferometry; (3) Consider co-expression with interacting partners.
Expression Yield Limitations:
Challenge: Membrane proteins often express at lower levels than soluble proteins.
Solutions: (1) Optimize codon usage for expression host; (2) Test different expression systems and conditions; (3) Consider fusion partners known to enhance expression; (4) Explore specialized E. coli strains designed for membrane protein expression.
Protein Misfolding:
Challenge: Ensuring proper folding outside the native membrane environment.
Solutions: (1) Express at lower temperatures; (2) Include molecular chaperones during expression; (3) Validate folding using circular dichroism or limited proteolysis.
Addressing these challenges requires systematic optimization and may benefit from comparative studies with ATP synthase components from better-characterized model organisms.
Inconsistent results when measuring ATP synthase activity across Nostoc punctiforme developmental stages can arise from multiple sources. Here are systematic approaches to address these challenges:
Standardize Sample Preparation:
Develop protocols for isolating specific cell types (heterocysts, akinetes, hormogonia) with minimal cross-contamination
Synchronize cultures before inducing differentiation (the zwf mutant system offers good synchronization for akinete studies )
Establish consistent cell disruption methods that preserve enzyme activity
Standardize protein extraction buffers and conditions
Optimize Assay Conditions:
Determine optimal pH, temperature, and ionic conditions for ATP synthase activity in each cell type
Test multiple assay methods (e.g., coupled enzyme assays, direct ATP production measurement)
Include appropriate controls for each developmental stage
Validate results using complementary approaches (e.g., oxygen consumption, membrane potential measurements)
Account for Biological Variables:
Measure ATP synthase subunit composition in different cell types, as this may vary
Consider the effects of different membrane compositions across developmental stages
Assess substrate availability (ADP, Pi) in different cell types
Control for potential endogenous inhibitors that may be present in specific developmental stages
Statistical and Experimental Design Approaches:
Increase biological and technical replicates
Use nested experimental designs to account for batch effects
Employ analysis of covariance (ANCOVA) to control for variables like protein concentration
Conduct power analyses to ensure sufficient sample sizes
Validation Strategies:
Correlate biochemical measurements with gene expression data
Confirm activity findings with in vivo ATP production measurements
Use ATP synthase inhibitors to verify specificity of measured activity
Compare results with those from related cyanobacterial species
When working with the zwf mutant system that forms akinete-like cells upon dark incubation with fructose , researchers should additionally control for metabolic differences from the oxidative pentose phosphate pathway disruption that might indirectly affect ATP synthase activity measurements.
Several emerging technologies hold promise for deepening our understanding of ATP synthase subunit b function in Nostoc punctiforme differentiation:
Advanced Imaging Technologies:
Cryo-electron tomography to visualize ATP synthase in situ within different cell types
Super-resolution microscopy (STORM/PALM) to track ATP synthase distribution during differentiation
Correlative light and electron microscopy to link protein localization with ultrastructural changes
Label-free imaging techniques to monitor ATP synthase activity in living cells
Genome Editing and Synthetic Biology:
CRISPR-Cas9 genome editing for precise modification of ATP synthase genes
Inducible degron systems for temporal control of ATP synthase component levels
Optogenetic tools to manipulate ATP synthase activity with spatiotemporal precision
Designer ATP synthase variants with altered properties for functional studies
Single-Cell Technologies:
Single-cell RNA-seq to capture cell-type specific transcriptional profiles
Single-cell proteomics to measure ATP synthase component abundance in individual cells
Single-cell metabolomics to correlate ATP levels with differentiation stages
Microfluidic systems for tracking individual filaments during differentiation
Structural Biology Advances:
Cryo-EM methodologies for membrane protein complexes at near-atomic resolution
Integrative structural biology combining multiple data types (NMR, SAXS, crosslinking)
Time-resolved structural methods to capture conformational changes during catalysis
In-cell structural biology approaches to study ATP synthase in its native environment
Systems Biology Approaches:
Multi-omics integration to connect ATP synthase function with global cellular processes
Metabolic flux analysis to quantify energy flow during differentiation
Constraint-based modeling to predict the impact of ATP synthase alterations
Network analysis to position ATP synthase in regulatory networks governing differentiation
These technologies could be particularly powerful when applied to the zwf mutant system that allows synchronized akinete formation , providing insights into how ATP synthase function changes during this developmental transition and potentially revealing new regulatory mechanisms governing cyanobacterial differentiation.
Understanding the evolutionary patterns of ATP synthase subunit b across cyanobacterial species offers several promising research directions:
Comparative Genomics and Phylogenetics:
Comprehensive phylogenetic analysis of atpF genes across diverse cyanobacterial lineages
Identification of selection pressures on different domains of the protein
Correlation of sequence variations with ecological niches and metabolic capabilities
Analysis of horizontal gene transfer events involving ATP synthase components
Structure-Function Relationship Across Species:
Comparative structural modeling of ATP synthase subunit b from diverse cyanobacteria
Identification of conserved interaction interfaces vs. species-specific features
Functional complementation studies swapping subunit b between species
Investigation of co-evolution patterns with other ATP synthase components
Developmental Biology Comparisons:
Examination of atpF expression patterns during cellular differentiation across species capable of forming heterocysts, akinetes, or hormogonia
Correlation of ATP synthase diversity with developmental complexity
Comparison of regulatory mechanisms controlling ATP synthase expression during differentiation
Investigation of how ATP synthase variations contribute to species-specific developmental capabilities
Experimental Evolution Studies:
Laboratory evolution experiments under different energy constraints
Analysis of ATP synthase adaptations to various environmental conditions
Reconstruction of ancestral ATP synthase sequences to test functional hypotheses
Directed evolution of ATP synthase components to understand adaptive landscapes
Synthetic Biology Applications:
Design of chimeric ATP synthase systems with components from different species
Engineering ATP synthase variants with novel properties based on natural diversity
Creation of minimal ATP synthase models based on conserved features
Development of biosensors utilizing evolutionary conserved domains
These research directions could leverage the detailed sequence information available for Nostoc punctiforme ATP synthase subunit b as a reference point for comparative studies, potentially revealing how variations in this crucial component contribute to the remarkable metabolic versatility and developmental complexity of cyanobacteria across diverse ecological niches.
Research on ATP synthase function in Nostoc punctiforme offers several valuable contributions to our broader understanding of bioenergetics in photosynthetic organisms:
Developmental Bioenergetics Model:
Nostoc punctiforme's ability to differentiate into specialized cell types (heterocysts, akinetes, hormogonia) provides a unique system to study how bioenergetic systems adapt to different cellular functions . Understanding how ATP synthase expression and activity are regulated during these transitions could reveal fundamental principles about energy allocation during cellular differentiation in all photosynthetic organisms.
Ecological Adaptation Insights:
As a terrestrial cyanobacterium capable of surviving extreme conditions (especially through akinete formation ), Nostoc punctiforme's ATP synthase may harbor adaptations that confer resilience to environmental stresses. These adaptations could inform our understanding of how photosynthetic energy conversion systems evolve in response to challenging environments.
Evolutionary Perspective:
Cyanobacteria were the progenitors of chloroplasts, making their ATP synthase a direct evolutionary ancestor to the chloroplast ATP synthase in plants and algae. Detailed characterization of Nostoc punctiforme ATP synthase structure and function can illuminate evolutionary transitions in this critical enzyme complex across the photosynthetic lineage.
Metabolic Flexibility Models:
Nostoc punctiforme can switch between photoautotrophic growth and heterotrophic metabolism , offering insights into how ATP synthase regulation facilitates these metabolic mode transitions. This could inform research on bioenergetic flexibility in other photosynthetic organisms, including crop plants under changing environmental conditions.
Biotechnological Applications:
Understanding the molecular details of ATP synthase function in this highly adaptable organism could inspire biomimetic approaches to energy conversion systems or guide engineering of more efficient photosynthetic organisms for biotechnology applications.
Symbiosis Research:
Nostoc species form symbiotic relationships with various plants and fungi, where energetic exchanges are crucial. ATP synthase function during these interactions could reveal important principles about bioenergetic coordination in symbiotic systems involving photosynthetic partners.
By leveraging the unique capabilities of Nostoc punctiforme, including its developmental versatility and the availability of genetic tools like the zwf mutant system , researchers can gain insights into ATP synthase function that extend far beyond this specific organism to inform our broader understanding of bioenergetics across the photosynthetic world.