Recombinant Pisum sativum ATP synthase subunit c, chloroplastic (atpH), is a genetically engineered protein derived from the chloroplast ATP synthase complex of garden peas (P. sativum). This subunit is critical for ATP synthesis during photosynthesis, functioning as part of the F₀ sector’s c-ring, which translocates protons across the thylakoid membrane to drive ATP production .
Gene: The atpH gene encodes the c-subunit, comprising 81 amino acids (UniProt: P08212) .
Structure: The subunit adopts an α-helical conformation, confirmed by circular dichroism (CD) spectroscopy .
Function: As a component of the c-ring, it facilitates proton translocation, with the ring’s stoichiometry (e.g., c₁₄ or c₁₅) determining the ion-to-ATP ratio .
Host System | Expression Strategy | Purity |
---|---|---|
E. coli | Synthetic atpH gene optimized for codon usage | ≥85% (SDS-PAGE) |
Yeast/Baculovirus | N/A | ≥85% |
Mammalian cells | N/A | ≥85% |
Cloning: A synthetic atpH gene is inserted into expression vectors for heterologous production .
Purification: Affinity chromatography (e.g., maltose-binding protein fusion tags) and gel filtration isolate the protein .
Proton Translocation: The c-ring’s rotation, driven by proton flux, couples to ATP synthesis via the F₁ sector .
Stoichiometry Engineering: Modifying the c-ring size (e.g., c₁₅ in transplastomic tobacco) alters proton-to-ATP ratios, enabling plants to maintain ATP production under varied conditions .
Subunit Interactions: The ε-subunit inhibits ATP hydrolysis by interacting with the β-subunit, while γ-subunit redox regulation modulates activity .
Post-Translational Modifications (PTMs): Acetylation and phosphorylation sites in α/β-subunits may regulate nucleotide binding and rotational efficiency .
Stoichiometry Manipulation: Engineering c-ring size (e.g., c₁₅) could enhance ATP yield in crops, improving photosynthetic efficiency .
Protein Reconstitution: Recombinant subunits enable in vitro assembly of c-rings to study stoichiometry and lipid interactions .
Expression Variability: Host-dependent folding and purification efficiency require optimization .
Stoichiometry Control: Maintaining precise c-ring subunit counts during recombinant production remains challenging .
ATP synthase subunit c (atpH) is a critical component of the chloroplastic ATP synthase complex (CF₁Fₒ-ATP synthase). The c-subunit forms a ring structure in the membrane-embedded Fₒ domain, functioning as the proton-conducting rotor that drives ATP synthesis.
Structurally, each c-subunit folds into a hairpin of two transmembrane helices connected by a short partially structured loop. Multiple c-subunits (typically 14 in plant chloroplasts) assemble into a cylindrical ring structure. The c₁₄-ring has these key dimensions:
Length: 60.32 Å
Outer ring diameter: 52.30 Å
Inner ring width: 40 Å
The c-ring works in concert with subunit a to form a proton channel. During photosynthesis, protons flow through this channel, causing the c-ring to rotate. This rotation is mechanically coupled to the F₁ sector, driving conformational changes that catalyze ATP synthesis .
High-resolution crystallographic studies (2.3 Å) of spinach chloroplast c-rings have revealed important features:
A network of hydrogen bonds stabilizing the ring structure
Intersubunit contacts that determine c-ring stoichiometry
Circular electron densities inside the hydrophobic part of the internal pore, potentially representing bound lipids or other molecules
The stoichiometry of c-rings (number of c-subunits) varies across species from 8 to 15 subunits. This variation affects the H⁺-to-ATP ratio, a crucial bioenergetic parameter. Researchers employ several complementary techniques to determine c-ring stoichiometry:
Atomic Force Microscopy (AFM):
AFM studies have demonstrated that chloroplast ATP synthase c-rings contain 14 symmetrically distributed subunits that protrude from both membrane surfaces .
X-ray Crystallography:
Crystallization and diffraction analysis can definitively establish c-ring stoichiometry. For example, crystallographic studies of spinach chloroplast c-rings confirmed 14 subunits in the asymmetric unit cell .
Mass Spectrometry:
Mass spectrometry of intact c-rings can provide stoichiometric information based on the molecular weight of the complex.
Genetic Engineering Approach:
Researchers can confirm c-ring stoichiometry by genetic modification followed by functional analysis. For example, in a study where the native tobacco atpH gene was replaced with the sequence from Spirulina platensis (known to have a c₁₅-ring), the modified ATP synthase exhibited altered function consistent with a c₁₅-ring structure .
Experimental Protocol for Crystallographic Analysis:
Isolate intact ATP synthase from chloroplasts
Extract c-rings using detergent solubilization
Purify by chromatography methods
Crystallize using in meso crystallization techniques
Collect X-ray diffraction data
Determine structure and count number of subunits in the ring
Recombinant expression of chloroplastic atpH presents challenges due to its hydrophobic nature and membrane integration. Based on established protocols, the following methods have proven effective:
Expression Systems:
E. coli: Most commonly used for atpH expression
Yeast: Suitable for higher eukaryotic protein folding
Baculovirus: Used for more complex expression needs
Mammalian cells: For specific post-translational modifications
Expression Vectors and Tags:
Fusion with maltose-binding protein (MBP) has been successfully employed for spinach c-subunit expression, improving solubility and purification efficiency .
High-Yield Expression Protocol:
Vector Construction:
Clone the atpH gene into an expression vector with an inducible promoter
Include a fusion tag to enhance solubility and purification
Transformation and Culture:
Transform into an appropriate E. coli strain (BL21(DE3), C41(DE3), or C43(DE3))
Use high-cell-density methods to maximize yield
Induction Strategies:
Expression Optimization:
This high-yield expression protocol can increase protein production by 9- to 85-fold compared to traditional methods .
Purifying membrane proteins like atpH requires specialized approaches. The following purification workflow has been successful for obtaining high-purity c-subunit:
Extraction and Solubilization:
Harvest cells by centrifugation
Resuspend in lysis buffer with protease inhibitors
Disrupt cells using sonication, high-pressure homogenization, or enzymatic lysis with lysozyme (0.2 mg/ml, 37°C, 15 min)
Isolate membranes by ultracentrifugation
Solubilize with appropriate detergent (e.g., n-dodecyl-β-D-maltoside or LDAO)
Purification Strategy:
For tag-based purification (if using a fusion protein approach):
Purification Step | Method | Purpose | Conditions |
---|---|---|---|
Affinity Chromatography | MBP-affinity or His-tag | Initial capture | Binding: PBS pH 7.4 Elution: 10 mM maltose or 250 mM imidazole |
Tag Cleavage | TEV or PreScission protease | Remove fusion tag | 16°C, overnight |
Size Exclusion | Superdex 200 | Remove aggregates and contaminants | Buffer: 20 mM Tris, 150 mM NaCl, 0.05% detergent |
For Tag-less Approach:
A minimal two-step purification method has been developed that may be applicable:
Buffer exchange using tangential flow filtration
Q-membrane filtration to remove impurities
This approach can yield 1-2 mg of protein with >60% purity, sufficient for many biophysical characterizations .
Quality Control:
SDS-PAGE: Assess purity (target: >85% as determined by densitometry)
Mass spectrometry: Confirm identity and detect modifications
Circular dichroism: Verify proper alpha-helical secondary structure
Crystallizing membrane protein complexes like the c-ring presents specific challenges that researchers must overcome:
Major Challenges:
Detergent Management: Finding detergents that maintain c-ring integrity while allowing crystal formation
Stability Issues: Maintaining the oligomeric state during purification and crystallization
Low Protein Yields: Obtaining sufficient quantities of pure, homogeneous protein
Crystal Packing: Achieving well-ordered crystals with minimal detergent-filled voids
Successful Crystallization Approach:
Researchers have successfully obtained high-resolution (2.3 Å) crystals of spinach chloroplast c₁₄-rings using in meso crystallization:
Starting Material: Begin with intact, active chloroplast F₁F₀-ATP synthase
Extraction Method: Selective extraction of the c-ring while maintaining its oligomeric state
Crystallization Conditions:
Alternative Approaches:
Lipidic cubic phase (LCP) crystallization
Reconstitution into nanodiscs prior to crystallization
Notably, researchers used a biochemically characterized preparation of the complete chloroplast F₁F₀-ATP synthase that showed high purity by SDS-PAGE and BN-PAGE, with the c-subunit migrating as an intact oligomer. The preparation maintained ATP synthesis activity (41±4 ATP per enzyme per second) after reconstitution into liposomes .
Genetic modification of atpH provides insights into structure-function relationships of the ATP synthase. Research on engineered c-rings has revealed fascinating adaptations:
Modification Approaches:
Gene Replacement: Substituting native atpH with variants from other species
Site-Directed Mutagenesis: Altering specific residues involved in proton conduction or ring stability
Promoter Modification: Altering expression levels of atpH
Case Study: c₁₄ to c₁₅ Ring Conversion:
In a landmark study, researchers replaced the tobacco atpH gene with a modified version based on Spirulina platensis (which naturally has a c₁₅-ring). The results revealed remarkable physiological adaptations:
Parameter | Wild Type (c₁₄) | Modified (c₁₅) | Significance |
---|---|---|---|
ATP Synthase Content | 100% | ~25% | Compensatory reduction |
Growth Rate | Normal | Normal | Physiological adaptation |
Electron Transport | Normal | Normal | Maintained photosynthetic capacity |
H⁺/ATP Ratio | 4.67 | 5.0 | Altered bioenergetic cost |
Membrane Potential | Lower | Higher | Compensation for altered H⁺/ATP ratio |
The transplastomic plants with c₁₅-rings maintained normal photosynthetic growth despite the drastically reduced ATP synthase content. They accomplished this by increasing the membrane potential component of the proton motive force, ensuring sufficient proton flux through the c₁₅-ring without inducing low pH-induced feedback inhibition of electron transport .
Methodology for atpH Modification:
Design synthetic atpH gene with desired modifications
Insert into a chloroplast transformation vector with selectable marker
Perform biolistic transformation of chloroplasts
Select for transformants and confirm homoplasmy
Analyze ATP synthase content by immunoblotting
This research demonstrates the remarkable adaptability of the photosynthetic apparatus to alterations in a key bioenergetic parameter.
Understanding the proton pathway through ATP synthase is crucial for elucidating its mechanism. Researchers employ several complementary techniques:
Structural Approaches:
Cryo-EM: High-resolution (2.9-3.4 Å) cryo-EM structures of complete chloroplast ATP synthase have revealed the proton pathway to and from the c-ring. This technique has successfully resolved sidechains of all 26 protein subunits .
X-ray Crystallography: Crystal structures of c-rings at high resolution (2.3 Å) show essential features of the proton-binding sites .
Spectroscopic Methods:
Electrochromic Pigment Absorbance Shift (ECS): This non-invasive technique measures changes in green light absorption by photosynthetic pigments to monitor electrical gradients across thylakoid membranes.
Light Scattering (LS): Used to measure proton gradients and pH changes in chloroplasts.
Experimental Protocol for Proton Gradient Measurement:
Sample Preparation: Use intact leaves or leaf segments
ECS Measurement: Record absorption changes at specific wavelengths (typically ~520 nm)
Analysis of Components:
ECS pmf: Measures the total proton motive force
ECS ΔpH: Measures the proton gradient component
ECS ΔΨ: Measures the electrical potential component
H⁺-ATP Synthase Activity: Determined from ECS relaxation kinetics
Key Findings:
A study on pea (Pisum sativum) leaves demonstrated that variation potential (VP, an electrical signal) decreased the rate constant of ECS relaxation, reflecting reduced proton conductivity of H⁺-ATP synthase. This effect was similar to artificially suppressing photosynthesis by lowering CO₂ concentration, suggesting a regulatory mechanism linking electrical signaling to ATP synthesis .
Measurement of ATP Synthase Activity:
Researchers can quantify ATP synthase activity by:
Reconstituting purified ATP synthase into liposomes
Applying an electrochemical proton gradient
Measuring ATP synthesis rates (e.g., 41±4 ATP per enzyme per second for spinach chloroplast ATP synthase)
Chloroplast ATP synthase has evolved a unique redox regulation mechanism that prevents wasteful ATP hydrolysis in the dark. This regulation involves a specific structural element in the γ-subunit:
Redox Switch Structure:
The chloroplast γ-subunit contains a conserved ~40 amino acid insertion not found in bacterial or mitochondrial homologs
This insertion forms two β-hairpins arranged in an L shape
Located between the nucleotide-free β subunit (βempty) and the γ-rotor
Contains redox-active cysteines that can form a disulfide bond
Mechanism of Action:
In the Dark (Oxidizing Conditions):
The γ-subunit hairpin forms a disulfide bond
This creates a β-hairpin "chock" that physically blocks rotation
ATP hydrolysis is prevented, conserving energy when photosynthesis is inactive
In the Light (Reducing Conditions):
Reducing equivalents from photosynthesis break the disulfide bond
The inhibitory conformation is released
Rotation is permitted, allowing ATP synthesis
Research Methods to Study Redox Regulation:
Site-Directed Mutagenesis: Modifying the cysteine residues to prevent disulfide formation
Structural Analysis: Using cryo-EM to visualize the conformational changes
Activity Assays: Measuring ATP synthesis/hydrolysis under different redox conditions
Cryo-EM studies at 2.9-3.4 Å resolution have directly visualized this regulatory mechanism, showing how the redox-controlled γ-subunit insertion physically blocks rotation in oxidizing conditions .
Physiological Significance:
This elegant regulation mechanism ensures that:
ATP synthesis occurs efficiently during photosynthesis
ATP is not wastefully hydrolyzed in the dark
Energy conservation is maintained during diurnal cycles
This represents a plant-specific adaptation that is not present in bacterial or mitochondrial ATP synthases.
Assessing proper assembly of recombinant atpH into functional c-rings requires specialized techniques:
Electrophoretic Methods:
Blue Native PAGE (BN-PAGE): Preserves native protein complexes during electrophoresis
SDS-PAGE with Sample Preparation Variations:
Without boiling: Intact c-rings often remain associated despite SDS treatment
With boiling: Complete dissociation into monomers for stoichiometry estimation
Semi-native conditions: Can reveal intermediate states of assembly
Microscopy Techniques:
Atomic Force Microscopy (AFM): Enables visualization of c-ring topology and subunit arrangement
Electron Microscopy: Single-particle analysis can resolve subunit organization
Functional Assays:
Reconstitution into Liposomes:
Incorporate purified c-rings into artificial membranes
Generate a proton gradient
Measure proton conductance
ATP Synthesis Activity:
Experimental Protocol for Assessing c-Ring Integrity:
Isolate membranes containing ATP synthase
Solubilize with mild detergent (1% digitonin)
Separate by BN-PAGE
Perform in-gel ATPase activity assay to confirm functional assembly
For higher resolution analysis, extract bands and analyze by mass spectrometry
The lipid environment plays a crucial role in c-ring stability and function. Recent research has revealed fascinating aspects of this protein-lipid interaction:
Key Lipid-Protein Interactions:
Internal Lipid Pore: High-resolution (2.3 Å) structures of c-rings from spinach chloroplasts revealed circular electron densities inside the hydrophobic part of the internal pore. These densities might represent isoprenoid quinones (such as plastoquinone in chloroplasts) .
Lipid Binding Sites: Specific lipid binding sites have been identified at the interface between c-subunits, contributing to ring stability.
Experimental Approaches to Study Membrane Effects:
Detergent Screening:
Different detergents can be systematically tested for their ability to maintain c-ring integrity during purification:
Mild detergents: digitonin, DDM
Medium strength: LDAO, C₁₂E₈
Harsh detergents: SDS, Triton X-100
Reconstitution Studies:
Purified c-rings can be reconstituted into:
Liposomes of defined lipid composition
Nanodiscs with controlled lipid environment
Native thylakoid membrane lipid extracts
Biophysical Characterization:
Differential scanning calorimetry (DSC) to measure thermal stability
Circular dichroism (CD) to assess secondary structure
Fluorescence spectroscopy to monitor conformational changes
Research Findings:
The c-ring shows unusual structural features in its hydrophobic core, with electron densities arranged in circles parallel to the membrane plane.
These features appear universal among ATP synthases from various species (archaea, bacteria, and eukaryotes).
Spectroscopic evidence suggests these may be isoprenoid quinones (like plastoquinone in chloroplasts).
The large distance between polar/apolar interfaces inside the c-ring (unusually wide hydrophobic region) supports this hypothesis .
This finding suggests a potential universal role for quinone-like molecules as cofactors in ATP synthases, possibly stabilizing the c-ring and preventing ion leakage through it.
Researchers studying atpH require reliable immunological tools. The following antibodies and methods have been validated for atpH detection:
Commercial Antibodies:
Anti-AtpH (AS05 071):
Type: Polyclonal
Host: Rabbit
Reactivity: Arabidopsis thaliana, Spinacia oleracea, Nicotiana benthamina, Thermosynechococcus elongatus
Predicted reactivity: Algae, Cannabis sativa, Cyclotella cryptica, Glycine max, Oryza sativa, Physcomitrium patens, Phaeodactylum tricornutum, Pisum sativum, Populus alba, Pinus thunbergii, Thalassiosira pseudonana, Zea mays, Vitis vinifera
Format: Lyophilized serum (200 μl)
Reconstitution: Add 200 μl of sterile water
Storage: -20°C (make aliquots after reconstitution)
Applications: Western blot
Immunodetection Protocol:
Sample Preparation:
For purified ATP synthase: Load 0.7-15 μg protein
For thylakoid preparations: Load 40-50 μg protein
Separate on 12% polyacrylamide gel
Transfer to PVDF membrane
Western Blot Procedure:
Detection Sensitivity:
The antibodies can detect both the monomeric c-subunit and intact c-rings in properly prepared samples, making them versatile tools for studying both the expression levels and assembly state of ATP synthase.
The energetics of proton transport through the c-ring is fundamental to understanding ATP synthesis. Researchers employ several approaches to study this process:
Biophysical Techniques:
Electrochromic Shift (ECS) Measurements:
Based on absorption changes in photosynthetic pigments
Provides real-time monitoring of electrical gradients
Components measured:
ECS pmf: Total proton motive force
ECS ΔpH: Proton gradient component
ECS ΔΨ: Electrical potential component
ECS Relaxation Kinetics:
Experimental Protocol for ECS Measurements:
Use intact leaves or leaf segments (e.g., 14-21 day-old pea seedlings)
Monitor absorption changes following light-to-dark transitions
Fit relaxation kinetics to determine rate constants
Compare under different conditions (e.g., normal vs. low CO₂)
Energetic Calculations:
The free enthalpy (ΔG) of ATP hydrolysis under physiological conditions in chloroplasts is approximately -51 kJ/mol. For a c₁₄-ring in chloroplasts:
Each proton contributes -51×3/14 or -10.9 kJ/mol to ATP synthesis
The three observed rotary states contribute energy differences of -43.7, -48.1, and -61.2 kJ/mol per step
Key Research Findings:
Unequal Energy Distribution:
Surprisingly, the three conformations of chloroplast ATP synthase are separated by rotations of 103°, 112°, and 145° (or 4, 4.4, and 5.6 c-subunits), rather than the expected equal distributions .
Peripheral Stalk Elasticity:
The peripheral stalk (subunits b and b') bends relative to the central axis, coupling F₁ elastically to F₀. This acts like an elastic spring, evening out energy differences between rotational states to optimize ATP synthesis .
Regulation by Electrical Signals:
Studies in pea leaves showed that variation potential (an electrical signal) decreased H⁺-ATP synthase activity by reducing the rate constant of ECS relaxation. This effect was similar to artificially suppressing photosynthesis by lowering CO₂ concentration .
These approaches have revealed sophisticated energy distribution and regulatory mechanisms that optimize ATP synthesis under varying conditions.
Producing high yields of recombinant atpH protein requires specialized strategies to overcome challenges associated with membrane protein expression:
Expression System Optimization:
High-Cell-Density Methods:
Autoinduction Approach:
Expression Protocol Refinements:
Multiple small-volume expressions (5 × 50 mL) instead of single large-volume (250 mL)
Lower post-induction temperatures (16-20°C) to improve protein folding
Codon optimization for the expression host
Co-expression with chaperones to assist folding
Fusion Tags to Enhance Solubility:
Maltose-binding protein (MBP) fusion has been successfully used for spinach c-subunit expression
Other potential fusion partners: Thioredoxin, SUMO, GST
Cleavable tags allow removal after purification
Extraction Optimization:
Different extraction methods can be employed based on the expression level and experimental goals:
Extraction Method | Conditions | Benefits | Limitations |
---|---|---|---|
Osmotic Shock | 2 volumes water to 1 volume packed cells | Lower protease release | Lower yield |
Enzymatic Digestion | Lysozyme 0.2 mg/ml, 37°C, 15 min | Gentle cell disruption | Lab scale only |
Glass Bead Grinding | Vortex with glass beads, repeated cycles | Physical method, less chemical dependency | Multiple steps required |
Freeze/Thaw | Freeze cells, thaw, resuspend by pipetting | Simple procedure | Often insufficient for complete lysis |
By combining these strategies, researchers have achieved yields of 17-34 mg of unlabeled protein from 50-mL cultures, providing sufficient material for structural and functional studies .
Mutations in the atpH gene provide valuable insights into structure-function relationships of ATP synthase. Research has revealed several important aspects:
Complete Gene Deletion:
When the entire atpH gene was replaced with a selectable marker (aadA cassette) in tobacco chloroplasts, plants were unable to grow without acetate supplementation. This confirms the essential nature of the c-subunit for photosynthetic ATP synthesis .
c-Ring Stoichiometry Modification:
By converting the conserved glycine-rich motif in tobacco atpH from GLAVGLASIGPGVGQGT to aLAVGigSIGPGlGQGq (modeled after Spirulina platensis), researchers created plants with a c₁₅-ring instead of the normal c₁₄-ring. Key findings included:
ATP Synthase Content: Reduced to approximately 25% of wild-type levels
Subunit Composition: Levels of various ATP synthase subunits (AtpH, AtpF, AtpA, AtpB) were all decreased to less than 50% of wild-type levels
Growth: Despite reduced ATP synthase content, plants grew normally
Photosynthetic Electron Transport: Remained unaffected
Bioenergetic Adaptation: Increased contribution of membrane potential to proton motive force compensated for the altered H⁺/ATP ratio
Molecular Basis of c-Ring Assembly:
The sequence surrounding the glycine repeats is highly conserved in angiosperms and critical for proper c-ring assembly. The interface between c-subunits contains a network of hydrogen bonds that determines correct oligomerization .
Experimental Approach for Studying atpH Mutations:
Vector Construction:
Design mutations in the atpH gene
Clone into vector containing selectable marker (e.g., aadA cassette)
Include suitable flanking sequences for homologous recombination
Transformation:
Biolistic transformation of chloroplasts
Selection on medium with antibiotic
Verification of homoplasmy by DNA hybridization
Analysis:
This research demonstrates that while the c-subunit is essential, plants can adapt to significant changes in ATP synthase content and c-ring stoichiometry through remarkable compensatory mechanisms.
The atpH gene has valuable applications as a genetic marker for plant identification and molecular taxonomy studies:
Advantages of atpH as a Genetic Marker:
Location within the large single copy region of the chloroplast genome
Suitable rate of sequence evolution for species discrimination
Conserved regions for primer design flanking variable regions
Successful amplification from DNA of varied quality and concentration
Applications in Plant Research:
The chloroplast atpF-atpH intergenic region has been effectively used for:
Molecular systematic studies in plants
DNA barcoding for species identification
Phylogenetic analysis and molecular taxonomy
Experimental Methodology:
DNA Extraction:
Extract DNA from silica-dried leaves
Assess quality by spectrophotometry (OD 260/280 ratio)
PCR Amplification:
Sequence Analysis:
Sequence PCR products
Align sequences for comparison
Identify polymorphisms for species discrimination
Performance Comparison:
When compared with other chloroplast markers (trnH-psbA, psbK-psbI, rpoB, rpoC1, matK, rbcL), the atpF-atpH region has shown good amplification success and suitable variation for species discrimination .
This application demonstrates how a fundamental component of the photosynthetic machinery also serves as a valuable tool for plant evolutionary studies and biodiversity assessment.